Nomination Questions, #1
Jan. 25th, 2018 01:02 am![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
hetswapmod posting in ![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png){kind=small}
hetswapSpecific questions/comments about nominations under the cut!
Corruption of Champions
The Kelt, Minotaur, and Ceraph nominations have been approved, but I need some evidence that the Tentacle Beast has a perception of its gender/consciousness since the wiki only refers to it with 'it' pronouns.
The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel (TV)
The wiki has Penny's last name as Pann, is that more correct?
Fire Emblem
According to the Wiki, Morgan & My Unit can be male or female, so I've added a gender to the following two ships. If you think the tags were already self-explanatory (is the name Robin only used for the male version?), I can change it back.
1) Male Marc | Morgan/Nn | Nah (FE:A)
2) Male My Unit | Reflet | Robin/Sallya | Tharja (FE:A)
Peggy Carter (MCU)/Steve Trevor (Wonder Woman)
I've changed this to "Peggy Carter (MCU)/Steve Trevor (Wonder Woman 2017)" to be more specific. Please let me know if this was not the Steve Trevor you meant.
Star Wars - All Media Types
CT-7567 | Rex/Ahsoka Tano
Leia Organa/Han Solo
Please change your nominations to a more specific version of Star Wars.
Based on the nominations, Tolkien has been broken up into The Hobbit (Jackson Movies) & The Lord of the Rings (Movies) & The Lord of the Rings - J. R. R. Tolkien. Please check to make sure your nomination has gone into the right category.
DC's Arrowverse (TV)
Kara Danvers/Braniac 5
Kara Danvers/Querl Dox
I've only approved the second since I believe these are the same ship, but let me know if I'm mistaken.
Rejected on the basis of being platonic ships:
Jyn Erso & Bodhi Rook
Sameen Shaw (Person of Interest) & Eliot Spencer (Leverage)
I've added the romantic versions of these ships and edited the nominations guidelines to make things clearer.
Rejected on the basis of having more than two people:
Barry Allen/Leonard Snart/Iris West
Claudius/Costin/Dawn Madison
Kira Nerys/Keiko O'Brien/Miles O'Brien
RWBY nominator(s), some of the nominated ships have "(VLD)" after them. What does that indicate?
Ghira Belladonna/Kali Belladonna (VLD)
Blake Belladonna/Sun Wukong (VLD)
Mercury Black/Emerald Sustrai (VLD)
It's also been pointed out to me that if I reject a fandom, then I won't see any new nominations added under that fandom in my panel. I previously rejected several variations of DC's Arrowverse plus The Flash fandom category, so please don't nominate under those! Any relationships should go under "DC's Arrowverse (TV)". Anyone who nominated a tag that was rejected also can't change that slot to something else, so if you've been affected and have run out of fandom/pairing slots, leave a comment below with what you'd like to nominate and I'll add those tags manually. From now on, if the situation calls for it I'll ask people to change their nominated fandoms/pairings and reject them only after a few days of no answer.
Let me know below if a tag is in the wrong category, your nomination hasn't been approved and isn't mentioned in the above notes, your nomination has been wrongly deleted, you believe a nominated relationship doesn't fit the pairing guidelines, you see a misspelling, etc.
Corruption of Champions
The Kelt, Minotaur, and Ceraph nominations have been approved, but I need some evidence that the Tentacle Beast has a perception of its gender/consciousness since the wiki only refers to it with 'it' pronouns.
The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel (TV)
The wiki has Penny's last name as Pann, is that more correct?
Fire Emblem
According to the Wiki, Morgan & My Unit can be male or female, so I've added a gender to the following two ships. If you think the tags were already self-explanatory (is the name Robin only used for the male version?), I can change it back.
1) Male Marc | Morgan/Nn | Nah (FE:A)
2) Male My Unit | Reflet | Robin/Sallya | Tharja (FE:A)
Peggy Carter (MCU)/Steve Trevor (Wonder Woman)
I've changed this to "Peggy Carter (MCU)/Steve Trevor (Wonder Woman 2017)" to be more specific. Please let me know if this was not the Steve Trevor you meant.
Star Wars - All Media Types
CT-7567 | Rex/Ahsoka Tano
Leia Organa/Han Solo
Please change your nominations to a more specific version of Star Wars.
Based on the nominations, Tolkien has been broken up into The Hobbit (Jackson Movies) & The Lord of the Rings (Movies) & The Lord of the Rings - J. R. R. Tolkien. Please check to make sure your nomination has gone into the right category.
DC's Arrowverse (TV)
Kara Danvers/Braniac 5
Kara Danvers/Querl Dox
I've only approved the second since I believe these are the same ship, but let me know if I'm mistaken.
Rejected on the basis of being platonic ships:
Jyn Erso & Bodhi Rook
Sameen Shaw (Person of Interest) & Eliot Spencer (Leverage)
I've added the romantic versions of these ships and edited the nominations guidelines to make things clearer.
Rejected on the basis of having more than two people:
Barry Allen/Leonard Snart/Iris West
Claudius/Costin/Dawn Madison
Kira Nerys/Keiko O'Brien/Miles O'Brien
RWBY nominator(s), some of the nominated ships have "(VLD)" after them. What does that indicate?
Ghira Belladonna/Kali Belladonna (VLD)
Blake Belladonna/Sun Wukong (VLD)
Mercury Black/Emerald Sustrai (VLD)
It's also been pointed out to me that if I reject a fandom, then I won't see any new nominations added under that fandom in my panel. I previously rejected several variations of DC's Arrowverse plus The Flash fandom category, so please don't nominate under those! Any relationships should go under "DC's Arrowverse (TV)". Anyone who nominated a tag that was rejected also can't change that slot to something else, so if you've been affected and have run out of fandom/pairing slots, leave a comment below with what you'd like to nominate and I'll add those tags manually. From now on, if the situation calls for it I'll ask people to change their nominated fandoms/pairings and reject them only after a few days of no answer.
Let me know below if a tag is in the wrong category, your nomination hasn't been approved and isn't mentioned in the above notes, your nomination has been wrongly deleted, you believe a nominated relationship doesn't fit the pairing guidelines, you see a misspelling, etc.
